Is prop money illegal in the US? 12 scenarios against federal law
Updated · By Larpea
Larping for content is not illegal under the US federal texts we read: a labelled mockup or an AI photo with its label breaks none of them. It becomes illegal when the image is used to get money, a loan, a sale or trust. Prop banknotes have their own rules. This page is not legal advice.
The US page of the guide
This page takes the United States piece of is larping illegal and checks it against the federal texts, one by one. State law adds its own forgery and deceptive-practice offences; we have not read those, so a scenario marked lawful here is lawful under the federal texts only.
The eight federal texts
Each row links the official text and states what it covers. Where the text states a maximum penalty, the row quotes it; where it does not, the row says so rather than guessing.
This is general information, not legal advice. Law not reviewed by a lawyer.
Law checked on .
| Instrument | Article | What it covers | Maximum cited by the text | Read on |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wire fraud, 18 U.S.C. | § 1343 | A scheme to defraud, or to get money or property by false pretenses, carried out by wire, radio or television communication across state or national lines. A fake balance sent by message to win a deal fits the pattern. | 20 years; 30 years and a fine of up to $1,000,000 when the offence affects a financial institution | |
| False statements to lenders, 18 U.S.C. | § 1014 | Knowingly making a false statement or report, or willfully overvaluing property or security, to influence the listed federal agencies and institutions on a loan, credit or similar application. | A fine of up to $1,000,000 or up to 30 years, or both | |
| Bank fraud, 18 U.S.C. | § 1344 | A scheme to defraud a financial institution, or to obtain money or property in its custody by false or fraudulent pretenses. | A fine of up to $1,000,000 or up to 30 years, or both | |
| FTC Act, section 5 (15 U.S.C.) | § 45(a)(1) | Declares unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce unlawful. It is the base for the FTC's cases on deceptive earnings claims. | Not stated in the text | |
| Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, 16 CFR Part 465 | § 465.2 | A business may not write, create or sell a review or testimonial that misrepresents that the reviewer exists, used the product, or what the experience was; nor buy or spread one it knew or should have known was false. | Not stated in the text | |
| Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, 16 CFR Part 465 | § 465.8 | Selling, distributing, buying or procuring fake indicators of social media influence (followers, views, likes) that the person knew or should have known were fake, when they could be used to materially misrepresent influence or importance for a commercial purpose. | Not stated in the text | |
| Business Opportunity Rule, 16 CFR Part 437 | § 437.4 | A seller of a business opportunity needs a reasonable basis and written substantiation for any earnings claim, and must give an earnings claim statement with the period and the share of buyers who reached the figure. The rule covers only a business opportunity as § 437.1(c) defines it: the seller says it will provide locations, outlets, accounts or customers, or buy back what the buyer makes. | Not stated in the text | |
| Impersonation Rule, 16 CFR Part 461 | § 461.3 | Materially and falsely posing as a business or one of its officers, or materially misrepresenting affiliation with, endorsement by or sponsorship by a business, in or affecting commerce. | Not stated in the text |
What the texts have in common
None of the eight mentions larping, mockups or content. They ask three plain questions: was a claim made, did someone rely on it, and was something obtained. A labelled wallet screen answers no to all three. A balance shown to a lender answers yes to all three.
Two details matter for people who film. The wire fraud text needs a communication sent in interstate or foreign commerce, which an online message or a call often is. And the lender text is about the statement made to influence the lender, so the offence is the false statement itself rather than a loss that follows.
Twelve scenarios
These are the questions people type into search boxes, answered with the text that settles them.
| What you do | Our reading | Why, with the text |
|---|---|---|
| Film a wallet or card mockup for a video, with “mockup” in the caption | Lawful | Nothing is claimed as real and no one relies on it. None of the texts above reaches it. |
| Post an AI photo of yourself on a jet, labelled as AI | Lawful | No federal text we read requires a label for a personal post; platforms do (see how to label AI photos). |
| Show a made-up balance to a mortgage or loan officer | Illegal | False statements to influence a lender: 18 U.S.C. § 1014 and, for a bank, § 1344. |
| Message a made-up balance to a seller or investor to win a deal | Illegal | A scheme to get money by false pretenses, sent over a wire: 18 U.S.C. § 1343. |
| Sell a course with income screenshots that are not real | Illegal | A deceptive earnings claim (FTC Act § 5); a seller of a business opportunity also needs substantiation (16 CFR § 437.4). |
| Present your one best real month as what buyers will earn | Depends | The Business Opportunity Rule asks for the period and the share of buyers who reached the figure (§ 437.4); a lone best case is the weak spot. |
| Buy followers or views to look bigger for brand deals | Illegal | Buying fake indicators of social media influence that you knew or should have known were fake, when they materially misrepresent influence for a commercial purpose: 16 CFR § 465.8. |
| Write five-star reviews of your own product under invented names, or pay buyers only for five-star ones | Illegal | 16 CFR § 465.2 covers reviews that misrepresent that the reviewer exists, used the product or what the experience was; paying for reviews that express a particular sentiment is a separate violation of the same rule (§ 465.4). |
| Put a real company's name and logo on a joke mockup | Depends | Trademark claims need use in commerce and a likelihood of confusion (15 U.S.C. § 1114); posing as the company to consumers is what § 461.3 targets. |
| Run a storefront that poses as a real brand and take orders | Illegal | Materially and falsely posing as a business in commerce (16 CFR § 461.3), and wire fraud (§ 1343) if paid orders are taken online with no intent to deliver. |
| Post a made-up trade result as an obvious, labelled joke | Lawful | No claim is made that anyone could rely on. |
| Use a made-up trade history to sell a paid signal group | Illegal | The track record is the earnings claim: FTC Act § 5 and, over a wire, § 1343. |
The FTC rules that creators miss
The review and follower rule is the one that surprises people. The e-CFR source note for 16 CFR Part 465 gives its Federal Register citation, 89 FR 68077, dated 22 August 2024. Section 465.8 is about buying or selling fake indicators of influence, and it applies when they could be used to materially misrepresent influence for a commercial purpose. Following a brand deal, a bought audience stops being vanity and becomes a representation to the brand.
The Business Opportunity Rule works the other way round. It does not ban an earnings claim; it demands a reasonable basis, written proof on request, and a statement of the period and of how many buyers reached the number. It is narrow, though: it covers only a business opportunity as the rule defines one, where the seller says it will provide locations, outlets, accounts or customers, or buy back what the buyer makes. Most courses fall outside that definition and are judged under section 5 of the FTC Act instead. A claim built on a screenshot nobody can verify has none of what the rule asks for. For how to read one from the outside, see how to spot fake income screenshots.
The Impersonation Rule is narrow: it covers materially and falsely posing as a business, or misrepresenting an affiliation, endorsement or sponsorship, in or affecting commerce. A parody that no consumer could take for the company sits far from it.
What this means for four kinds of screen
Larpea makes larp apps. We have an interest in the honest side of this line and we say so: each of the apps named here makes labelled mockups, and our terms forbid using any result as proof. This page describes laws; it does not tell you how to get around one.
- Revenue dashboards. A labelled Flextripe screen in a skit is lawful. The same screen sent to a prospect as proof of sales is the scenario that ends in 16 CFR § 437.4 or § 1343.
- Sales notifications. My Larp Notifs makes a labelled notification for film. Shown to a buyer or a bank as a record, it is evidence of a claim.
- Creator stats. LarpTube Studio is for mockup analytics in video. A real brand deal priced on its numbers is the § 465.8 problem.
- Bank screens. Revolarp makes labelled balances for content. The loan, rental or deal that depends on one is the §§ 1014 and 1344 problem.
Make it, check it, know the law
Law is one third of the picture. The other two are how a mockup is made well, and how anyone can tell whether a screen they were sent is real.
- Crypto wallet screens: the wallet screen tutorial and how to spot a fake crypto wallet screenshot.
- Hardware wallets: Flexdger Wallet to make one; how to tell if a hardware wallet is fake to check one.
- Sales and income: fake sales notifications, filmed honestly and ecom larping, explained to make; fake income screenshots to check.
- Creator numbers: how to make a larp video to make; how to spot fake followers to check.
- Resale: My Larp Resell to make a labelled seller dashboard; how to spot a fake receipt to check one.
- Trading results: PnL cards, explained to make; how to spot a fake PnL card to check.
What this page does not cover
State law, tax law, platform rules and contracts are outside it. Prop banknotes are covered in prop money for videos, because the answer is the same across the country and different from every other country. For other jurisdictions, see the UK page; the euro rules are in the Europe section of that guide.